The section on homework that should be used to enhance the writing workshop was very interesting to me. All the writing homework I used to receive was exactly the kind that the book mentions, worksheets with many examples of compound, run-on and various other types of sentence structures that you must identify. I never thought to use homework as a time to gather topics and ideas to write about at school. This is genius because in school sometimes students get stuck and don’t know what to write about because they are confined to the four walls of the classroom and a desk. I know I’ve been there. However, if they have taken down many interesting ideas and conversations that happen in everyday life and in their own world then they have a multitude of resources to pull from, which also makes their writing time during class more productive.
The section on teaching conventions (ways to expect things) was very interesting. The author explains that these should normally be taught in small group and individual student conferences and not in whole class discussions if students already know them. I can understand this but how can you check for student understanding? For example, if a student uses correct subject verb agreement in a piece how can you be sure they actually know it and need no further instruction on it or if it was just a lucky guess? I personally think that even if students are familiar with a convention they could always use the extra practice. Maybe a teacher could provide time in a whole group lesson on a certain convention for students that know the convention well to help explain it to groups of classmates so everyone gets practice with it instead of just a chosen few.
The last thing I would like to comment on in this post is how helpful this book really is. It goes into such detail things that most books would vaguely comment on assuming a teacher knows how to teach it. For example, in chapter 10 when it goes through each of the kinds of things the author finds important in a writing workshop, it gives specific examples of ways to teach each of these and also the main points of importance. I plan to keep this book after this class because it will be such a useful resource when I am planning my writing workshop curriculum. This book is also very inspirational, which I like. It encourages a general love for writing and gives much helpful insight to help your students view it that way too. After reading these three chapters this week I feel like I have a much better idea of how to fully conduct a writing workshop on a day to day basis.
I am so glad you like the book - I have stayed with it just for the reasons you mentioned. It is getting older, but I haven't figured out a replacement quite yet. Thanks for the positive feedback about it.
ReplyDeleteI think Ray's ideas about life as homework make a lot of sense. Again, it also makes the connections between life and what we do in school which is so important.
Your thoughts about conventions are interesting. I think your balance of whole group and small group/individual balance will work well. We will definitely talk more about conventions as we go on.